The French government has decided to delay the legalization of online casinos following significant resistance from physical casino operators and concerns raised by gambling addiction advocates. The move has reignited debate over the future of gambling in one of Europe’s most restrictive jurisdictions.
France’s Unique Gambling Landscape
France is one of only two European Union countries, alongside Cyprus, that continues to ban online casinos. Despite the prohibition, an estimated three million French residents participated in online gambling in 2023, often through offshore platforms, according to the Autorité Nationale des Jeux (ANJ).
Legalizing online casinos was projected to bring in €1 billion annually in tax revenue while enabling better oversight of gambling activities. Proponents argue this could provide tools to address addiction and promote responsible gambling practices.
However, the nation’s unique gambling history and its tightly regulated industry have made the proposal a hot-button issue.
Physical Casinos Raise Economic Alarms
The most vocal opposition has come from Casinos de France, the trade association representing the nation’s 200 physical casinos. These establishments collectively contributed €2.7 billion to the €13.4 billion generated by legal gambling activities in 2023.
The association warns that online casino legalization could lead to a 20% to 30% revenue decline for physical casinos, threatening around 15,000 jobs and forcing one-third of casinos to shut down.
Their proposed solution? Restrict any new online licenses to operators of existing physical casinos. This model, they argue, would help maintain balance in the industry and mitigate potential job losses.
- French Loto (2023)
- Total bets: €21 billion
- Winnings paid out: €14.5 billion
- Tax and social contributions: €4.2 billion
- Pari Mutuel Urbain (PMU)
- Allowed online since 2010
- 2023 net profit: €800 million
- Funds reinvested in horse racing and trotting organizations
The high stakes underscore the significant role gambling plays in France’s economy and culture.
Historical Roots of France’s Gambling Laws
France’s approach to gambling has always been restrictive, reflecting deep-seated concerns over its social impact. In 1919, casinos were banned within 100 kilometers of Paris, a rule aimed at protecting workers from vice. This restriction was later eased, allowing certain spa towns like Enghien-les-Bains to operate casinos.
A major shift occurred in 1988 when a law enabled casinos to open in cities without a tourism focus. This reshaped the landscape, giving rise to both grandiose venues and utilitarian establishments like the large casino in Bordeaux.
The current debate is the latest chapter in the country’s cautious approach to expanding gambling options.
A Push for Online Gambling
Online gambling isn’t entirely new in France. The privatized French Loto introduced online services around 15 years ago, while the PMU expanded into online betting in 2010, adding sports betting and poker to its portfolio.
The government had initially planned to fast-track online casino legalization via a decree but paused the process late last year to allow for further consultation.
Stakeholders are split:
- Supporters argue legalization could generate significant tax revenue and offer tools for safer gambling.
- Opponents worry about job losses in physical casinos and increased gambling addiction rates.
Challenges Ahead
As France weighs its options, it faces the difficult task of balancing economic opportunity with social responsibility. The shadow of offshore gambling looms large, with millions of French citizens already turning to unregulated platforms. Meanwhile, other EU nations have adopted hybrid models, legalizing online casinos while maintaining robust regulatory oversight.
For now, the French government’s cautious approach reflects its determination to navigate a path that minimizes harm while acknowledging the evolving nature of the gambling industry.
Leave a Reply